In 2012, a woman's left kidney disappeared and questioned the hospital that operated on her. The hospital retorted: your problem.
The experienced B-ultrasound doctor looks at the B-ultrasound picture that the patient has just handed in, and the two kidneys will follow the person for life until death. But it is almost impossible for such a child to survive in complete health. It is impossible for a girl to lose her left kidney without surgery. The doctor asked the girl about her medical history again and showed the scar of a splenic rupture operation eight years ago in front of the doctor. What did the hospital that operated on the girl say at that time? And I haven't had any kidney-related surgery. They know nothing about their daughter's body. How could there be something wrong with their daughter's kidney? It may be that there is something wrong with the examination of the Yan'an people's Hospital, which means that Gao Jing's kidney has really disappeared. Looking at the same test results given by different hospitals, it means that her life could end at any time because of the lost kidney. But the operation had nothing to do with the kidney!
In December 2012, the examination room of Yan'an people's HospitalThe experienced B-ultrasound doctor looked at the B-ultrasound picture that the patient had just handed in in front of him, and fell into doubt and confusion.
The confusion is that the B-ultrasound shows that thisThe 24-year-old girl's left kidney disappeared.But according to the patient's medical history and self-report, she has been in good health.There has never been a kidney-related disease. How could the kidney be missing?
It is important to know that two grams of kidneys are inevitable organs at birth, and without surgical removal, these two kidneys will follow a person for life until death.
Unless it is a deformed child born with only one kidney, it is almost impossible for such a child to survive in complete health..
Therefore, no matter in the field of physiology or biology, it is impossible for a girl to lose her left kidney without surgery.This is against the common sense of human medicine.!
After learning that her left kidney disappeared, the girl also showed strong doubt that she was a good person, how could she have only one kidney?She hurriedly asked the doctor if she had read it wrong, or if there was something wrong with the B-ultrasound.
But this B-ultrasound doctor has been seen many times.The result of kidney loss can't be wrong. How dare he joke about such a thing?
Therefore, in a rigorous and responsible attitudeThe doctor asked the girl again about her medical history and asked if she had any experience of surgery.
Hearing the doctor's words, the girl suddenly thought of something and hurriedly pulled up her coat.I had a surgical scar on a ruptured spleen eight years ago.In front of the doctor.
For a moment, a bold and terrible conjecture sprang up in their minds. So where did the girl's kidney go? What did the hospital that operated on the girl say at that time?
First, the lost left kidney
2012 was an extremely happy year for Gao Jing, 24. Because in this year, she successfully got a job in Yan'an Management Institute of Shaanxi Expressway Construction Group Company, became a state-owned enterprise employee and had a stable income.
On the other hand, Gao Jing has gained the pursuit and admiration of many excellent young men by virtue of her own efforts and good appearance. Look atCareer and love both come, Gao Jing is full of longing for the future!
However, to her surprise, all this beauty was broken in a physical examination arranged by the company at the end of the year: because the results of the physical examination showedHer body is missing a left kidney..
Seeing the result, Gao Jing suddenly fell into collapse and shock, and she kept asking the doctor if there was something wrong with the test results.But the doctor clearly told her that there was no problem, and her left kidney was indeed gone.
For Gao Jing, this fact was like a bolt from the blue. You know, she has been in good health since she was a child, and colds and fever are rare on weekdays, and she has never had any kidney-related surgery.
But in order to make sure that her memory was not wrong, she specially called her parents and asked them if there was anything they were not telling her.
Gao Jing's parents on the other end of the phone are also shocked and confused. They know nothing about their daughter's body. They have taken good care of their daughter since childhood, even the little cold that the girl has had.Remember clearly, not to mention kidney surgery, how could there be a problem with my daughter's kidney?
Finally, after confirmation and discussion with her parents, Gao Jing thought:Maybe there was something wrong with the examination in Yan'an people's Hospital, which had a physical examination, so he decided to go to other hospitals for several times..
To this endGao Jing and her parents went to Ganquan County people's Hospital, Xijing Hospital of the fourth military Medical University, and the first affiliated Hospital of Xi'an Jiaotong University for inspection..
But whether it is a small hospital in my hometown or a large authoritative hospital, the results given are the same as those of the Yan'an people's Hospital, that is to say,Gao Jing's kidney really disappeared..
Looking at the same test results given by different hospitals, Gao Jing fell into a collapse, which she would never have thought of.She suddenly became a level 7 disabled person, which means that her life could end at any time because of this lost kidney..
As for love and a happy family, it has become an extravagant hope.After all, which healthy man would like to live with an unhealthy girl?
But for Gao Jing, she doesn't even have much time for sadness and pain at this time, becauseShe needs to find the truth about the loss of her kidney..
So what is the truth? It turns out that after her parents' recollection, Gao Jing had an operation eight years ago.But the operation had nothing to do with the kidney! But if it had to be investigated, the operation was the only clue!
The accident two or eight years ago
On July 18, 2004, the 16-year-old Gao Jing had an accident in her hometown of Ganquan, Shanxi, and fell heavily off her motorcycle.He was then sent to the best local Ganquan County people's Hospital for treatment.
In Ganquan County people's Hospital, the doctor told Gao Jing's parents that the accident broke Gao Jing's spleen.Surgical removal must be performed, or life may be in danger.
Listening to the doctor, Gao Jing and her parents didn't think much about it.After realizing that the consequences of the operation had little impact on the body, he immediately agreed to the hospital's arrangement..
Compared with major surgery, splenectomy is not dangerous and difficult, so four hours later, the chief surgeon in charge of Gao Jing pushed Gao Jing out of the ward.
Subsequently, Gao Jing was hospitalized by Ganquan County people's Hospital for follow-up treatment.
After recovering for a period of time, the people's Hospital of Ganquan County again gave Gao Jing a full-body examination, and the results showed that Gao Jing's body was normal.
Except for the spleen removed by the operation, there was nothing wrong with the body, so Gao Jing's parents happily took their daughter to go through the discharge formalities and returned home to rest..
Over the next few years, Gao Jing really had no physical problems, and she felt that her body was no different from that before the operation.Her study and work have not been greatly affected, the only difference is that she is more tired than before.
But Gao Jing paid no attention to this situation.She subconsciously thought that she had had an operation after all, and that it was natural for her body to be a little worse than before.
It was not until that physical examination that her kidney disappeared, Gao Jing and her parents woke up that the decline in her physical strength must be due to the loss of her left kidney.
So the loss of his kidneyIt absolutely has something to do with the splenectomy performed in Ganquan County people's Hospital eight years ago.
III. Ganquan County people's Hospital
Confused about the loss of his kidney, at the end of December 2012, Gao Jing's father returned to Ganquan County people's Hospital, where his daughter had surgery eight years ago.
I took all the files of my daughter's spleen rupture operation, and examined it carefully with my daughter to see if there were any details I had ignored before!
However, just before Gao Jing's spleen operation, the examination results showed that Gao Jing had two pairs before the operation.Kidneys exist. This means that Gao Jing's left kidney is very likely to be lost during the operation!
As a result, Gao Jing, who was not deeply involved in the world, was scared to collapse, and she asked her father trembling:"Dad, did the hospital cut out my kidney?"
For a moment, Gao Jing's father was furious with proof of several tests.Found the senior management of the people's Hospital of Ganquan County and asked the hospital to give an explanation..
But the hospital was silent and could not give an explanation for a long time.In an urgent situation, Gao Jing and her father contacted the local reporter and decided to ask Chang Wensen, the vice president of the hospital..
But even in front of the reporter with the camera, Vice President Chang Wensen was silent.Say perfunctory words from time to time, such as "We don't know about this situation", "this has nothing to do with our hospital", "this is your own problem" and so on.
The hospital is unwilling to answer questions directly.Gao Jing's father opened the file taken from the hospital and found the name of the doctor who operated on his daughter, Jia Junyi..
It is reported that eight years later, Jia Junyi was already the director of surgery at the people's Hospital of Ganquan City. The disappearance of Gao Jing's left kidney must have something to do with this Jia Junyi.
So soon after, Gao Jing's parents made several banners saying "murder for money in Ganquan County people's Hospital" and "stealing my daughter's kidney".He came to the door of Ganquan County people's Hospital and asked to meet Jia Junyi, who operated on Gao Jing at that time.
However, in the face of angry Gao Jing's parents and the broad masses of people who want to know the truth, Ganquan County people's Hospital still has its own way.
Not only without any indicationOn the contrary, Dr. Jia Junyi, who was supposed to go to work, took a long holiday and asked him to go home and have a rest. In the eyes of Gao Jing and her family, it was clear that it was to tell them, "it's no use, don't come.".
When the reporter arrived at the scene and asked Vice President Chang Wensen why he gave Jia Junyi a holiday and did not allow Gao Jing and his family to meet Jia Junyi.Chang Wensen said:
"the family is impulsive and we are afraid that they will cause personal harm to him when they see [Jia Junyi].In addition, Vice President Chang Wensen also made clear to reporters and family members the attitude of the hospital:
"you (Gao Jing) we (the hospital) have also considered and consulted relevant experts, and we feel that there are four possibilities:
First, could Gao Jing be congenital kidney loss or dysplasia?.
- Could it be ectopic? the third is whether it would be said that in the car accident, Gao Jing's left abdominal scratches caused severe contusions to the left renal tubules that led to atrophy.
Finally, there was a mistake in B-ultrasound after operation, and our hospital considered the renal atrophy that may occur due to other diseases during the nine years after operation."
Although there are many possibilities, it translates into one sentence:This matter has nothing to do with our hospital, the loss of kidney is only related to Gao Jing, it is her own problem.
But in fact, both the preoperative B-ultrasound and the postoperative physical examination results of Gao Jing's operation eight years ago showed that Gao Jing's kidney was good before and after operation.The four situations considered by the hospital are reasonable and impossible..
Vice President Chang Wensen's words made Gao Jing angry and helpless.It was also deadlocked because of the hospital's unilateral silence and escape..
But as the saying goes, there is no other way, just when Gao Jing's family is distressed by this matter, things take a turn for the better.
IV. The arrival of a connecting flight
Soon after this happened, due to the propaganda of Gao Jing's parents and local journalists, the matter gradually fermented in the Internet and the media.
The people's Hospital of Ganquan County gradually felt the pressure from public opinion and proposed to Gao Jing.The requirement that "judicial organs shall be selected by both parties to do judicial appraisal", and all results shall be judged by judicial expertise.
Gao Jing and her family chose to accept the hospital's proposal. So in the six months from December 2012 to July 13,Gao Jing successively went to many institutions, such as the Medical Accreditation Center affiliated to Fudan University, Xi'an Medical Association, Shaanxi Xi'an Zhongheng Judicial Appraisal Institute and so on..
In the end, all three appraisal institutions gaveThe people's Hospital of Ganquan County has the result of fault in the process of treating Gao Jing's injury caused by traffic accident.
And it is also clearly stated in the certificate:It is not ruled out that there is a causal relationship between the loss of Gao Jing's left renal function and the medical behavior of Ganquan County people's Hospital. Ganquan County people's Hospital's participation in Gao Jing's left kidney loss is 45%..
At the moment of getting the appraisal certificate, Gao Jing and her parents both collapsed, hugged and cried bitterly, and lost her left kidney.The truth was revealed at this moment, and it had something to do with the people's Hospital of Ganquan County.
However, after seeing the appraisal results issued by several hospitals, the people's Hospital of Ganquan County did not reveal to Gao Jingtan everything that happened during the operation that year.Still refused to accept the identification results with a strong attitude.
For a long time since then,The Gao Jing family traveled around the country all day to do relevant judicial expertise for Gao Jing, asking forensic experts about the truth about Gao Jing's kidney loss..
Among themDr. Li, a forensic doctor who participated in the identification of Gao Jing's kidney loss, believes that Gao Jing's kidney is very likely to be artificially removed during the operation eight years ago..
Because before Gao Jing's spleen was removed that year, the hospital told Gao Jing's parents:Local anesthesia is used in this operation, but general anesthesia is really used in the actual operation.
In theory, minor surgeries such as splenectomyThere is no need for general anesthesia at all, so why does the hospital suddenly change the method of anesthesia during Gao Jing's operation?
Secondly, the operation time of splenectomy is about 2 hours.But Gao Jing's operation took four hours..
From general anesthesia to semi-anesthesia, from 2 hours to 4 hours, what kind of tricks are there in this operation?
In this regard, even judicial expertise can not give an accurate answer, because the result of judicial identification can only exclude the possibility of Gao Jing liver resection in Ganquan County people's Hospital from the point of view of no doubt.
It is impossible to prove that the operation 8 years ago, Ganquan County people's Hospital is really artificial removal of Gao Jing's left kidney! In this way, things have reached an impasse again!
V. belated justice
At the end of 2013, under the leadership of my fatherGao Jing came to the court and sued Ganquan County people's Hospital and Jia Junyi, the chief surgeon who operated on her at that time..
In the face of such a doubtful case, it is very difficult for the court to give a satisfactory result to both sides. It can only take 45% of the appraisal results as the basis and require Ganquan County people's Hospital to bear 45% of the responsibility for Gao Jing's left kidney loss.
However, this result did not satisfy Gao Jing's family, and it was difficult for her to accept that she was only 45% responsible.The loss of her kidney had a real impact on her life, and what she needed was the actual compensation from the people's Hospital of Ganquan County..
So Gao Jing chose to withdraw the case in 2014, decided to continue with more authoritative medical appraisal, and filed a second appeal against Ganquan County people's Hospital in Yan'an Intermediate people's Court.
In this appeal,Gao Jing asked the people's Hospital of Ganquan County to compensate her for medical expenses, nursing fees, hospitalization food subsidies, disability compensation, mental consolation, missed work expenses, transportation expenses, and accommodation expenses for close relatives in handling medical accidents, totaling 262240 yuan.
At the same time, Gao Jing conducted another appraisal at the Forensic Forensic expertise Center of Xi'an Jiaotong University on April 15, 2016, and obtained the results of grade 7 disability.
Hard work is worth the good will. Under the influence of Gao Jing's family, on December 12, 2016, Yan'an Intermediate people's Court made a civil judgment.It was ruled that the medical fault of the people's Hospital of Ganquan City was established. Gao Jing won the case and won a compensation of 262240 yuan. The case is still here for final trial.
But this result still failed to satisfy the Gao Jing family. In their minds, the matter of the people's Hospital of Ganquan City was murder and murder.It is by no means a simple civil judgment that can end.So in the years that followed, Gao Jing and her family were still appealing for kidney loss.
Unfortunately, due to factors such as the fact that things have passed too long and the technology of legal identification is not enough to find out the truth, this matter has ended permanently in December 2016 in legal concept.
As for where Gao Jing's kidney is and where it has gone, there is still no accurate explanation. The only thing that can be confirmed is that Gao Jing's kidney is indeed lost.
Conclusion
Looking back on the whole case, although the court's decision has come into effect, no one knows whether Gao Jing's left kidney was removed by Ganquan County people's Hospital.
However, as a medical institution based on the people and serving the people, Ganquan County people's Hospital, from the medical accident during the operation to the escape and evasion after the incident, their performance in the whole incident is extremely disappointing.
As far as the hospital is concerned, this medical accident is difficult to have much impact on it.At a time when medical talents are scarce, Dr. Jia Junyi may continue to practice medicine, while Dean Chang Wensen may still be the dean.
But for Gao Jing, the victim of the case, the kidney loss was firmly pressed on her like a boulder, and she will live in the shadow of kidney loss for the rest of her life.